Skip to main content
Languages, Codes and their TechnologiesMediumSingle Choice

Languages, Codes and their Technologies Question

Statement

TEXT I

Available at: https://graciliano.com.br. Accessed on: February 6, 2024 (adapted).

TEXTO II
Histórias de ninar (adultos)
Houve um tempo — tão perto, e, ó, tão longe — em que a arte era um holofote na unha encravada, não um campeonato de melhores esmaltes.
Raskolnikov matava velhinhas, a família de Gregor Samsa o assassinava a "maçãzadas", Memórias póstumas de Brás Cubas (Machado de Assis) é o retrato mais perfeito de tudo o que tem de pior na sociedade brasileira, uma sequência tristemente hilária de ações moralmente condenáveis, atitudes pusilânimes, cálculos mesquinhos e maus passos cretinos.
A literatura, o cinema e o teatro vêm se transformando num exercício de lacração: o mal está sempre no outro, os protagonistas são ironmen/women da virtude. A pessoa sai da leitura ou da sessão não com a guarda abaixada, as certezas abaladas, mais próxima da verdade (ou, à falta de uma palavra melhor, da sinceridade): sai com suas certezas reforçadas.
A realidade é confusa. Contraditória. Muitas vezes incompreensível. A arte é onde tentamos nos mostrar nus, com todos os nossos defeitos.

PRATA, A. Available at: www1.folha.uol.com.br. Accessed on: January 12, 2024 (adapted).

With regard to art, Antônio Prata's position in Text II is similar to Graciliano Ramos's thesis in Text I, since both

#function of art#social criticism#comparative literature#text interpretation
A

They defend the dignity of the artists' profession.

B

They conclude that art reinforces personal beliefs.

C

They present poverty as inspiration for art.

D

They affirm the necessary destabilizing nature of art.

Correct
E

They attest that there are significant changes in artistic production.

Resolution & Explanations

Comparative Analysis of the Texts of Graciliano Ramos and Antonio Prata

The correct answer is option D) They affirm the necessary destabilizing character of art.


1. Graciliano Ramos' Central Thesis (Text I)

In his letter, Graciliano Ramos defends an art that originates from raw reality, from misery and suffering. The central point of his argument is his reaction to "horror" to the idea of art that, in a perfect world, would become superficial and empty ("chromes, pink angels"). For him, the strength and dignity of Portinari's art come precisely from its ability to portray the "misery" and "deformities" of life. Therefore, he values an art that annoyingthat moves through pain and confronting the viewer with a harsh reality, that is, an art that destabilizes Comfort.

2. Antonio Prata's Central Thesis (Text II)

Antonio Prata constructs a direct opposition between two types of art:

  • The art he values: It is a **"spotlight on the ingrown toenail"**This art form exposes what is painful, ugly, and imperfect in the human condition ("murder," "cruelty," "morally reprehensible actions"). The goal of this art is to leave the viewer with... "Guard down, certainties shaken". * The art he criticizes: It is a "best nail polish competition" or a "closing-out exercise," where the protagonists are perfect and the audience leaves with their... "reinforced certainties".

Like Graciliano, Prata advocates for an art that does not seek to please or confirm, but rather question, disturb and to show us "naked, with all our flaws." That is, by definition, a destabilizing character.

3. The Point of Approximation Between the Authors

Both authors agree that art loses its value and power when it becomes merely pleasing, decorative, or comforting.

  • What Graciliano calls "pink angels," Prata calls "the championship of best nail polishes." * What Graciliano values in "the mother with the dead child," Prata values in "the ingrown toenail."

The common argument is that authentic and necessary art is that which has the courage to be uncomfortable, to confront the public with the complexities, pains, and flaws of reality. It must shake, not merely confirm. That is the... necessary destabilizing character of art.

4. Evaluation of Other Alternatives

  • A) They defend the dignity of the artists' profession: Although Graciliano mentions "the most dignified work," the focus of both texts is not the profession, but the... function and the nature of art. * B) They conclude that art reinforces personal beliefs: This alternative accurately describes the type of art that Antonio Prata... criticism. * C) They present poverty as inspiration for art: This is Graciliano's specific example, but Prata's argument is broader, including moral and psychological misery, not just material poverty. * E) They attest that there are significant changes in artistic production: Only Prata explicitly focuses on change over time. Graciliano's argument is more about the nature of art itself than about historical transformation.