Skip to main content
Humanities and their TechnologiesMediumSingle Choice

Humanities and their Technologies Question

Statement

TEXT I

Aristotle understood that happiness was directly linked to respect for one's own nature and, in a way, to a life that had its own nature as an unwavering reference point. This allowed him to formulate the concept of excellence. What would excellence be? It would be, precisely, throughout life, to draw from oneself, in the form of performance, conduct, behavior, and disposition, the best that nature would allow.

COEN, M.; BARROS FILHO, C. The nun and the professor: reflections on ethics, precepts and values. Rio de Janeiro: Best Seller, 2018.

TEXT II

The notion of eudaimonia It is central to Aristotelian ethics. eudaimonia It is an activity and not a psychological state, as it is defined in Nicomachean Ethics Ethics is seen as an activity of the soul based on moral virtue. Moral virtue is defined in terms of a disposition directly linked to deliberation, which leads to the study of the intellectual virtue that operates within it, that is, prudence. The conceptual structure of Aristotelian ethics responds to an attempt to conceptually elucidate what it means to act well, or, in Aristotelian language, what it means to be happy.

ZINGANO, M. Eudaimonia, reason and contemplation in Aristotelian ethics. Analytica, no. 1, 2017 (adapted).

The texts indicate that the practice of virtuous actions, always carried out in the polis, occurs through the

#ancient philosophy#ethics#Aristotle#virtue
A

theory of essential forms.

B

identification of rational principles.

C

development of rhetorical techniques.

D

Improvement of human behavior.

Correct
E

knowledge of true epistemologies.

Resolution & Explanations

1. Contextualization and Overview

The question addresses the core of Aristotle's moral philosophy: the inseparable relationship between happiness (eudaimonia), moral excellence (arete) and practical action in the context of the political community (polis).

Both supporting texts converge on the understanding that Aristotelian ethics is essentially practical and teleological:

  • THE Text I He defines moral excellence as the ability to draw from oneself, throughout life and in the form of conduct, behavior, and disposition, the best that human nature itself makes possible.
  • THE Text II emphasizes that eudaimonia It is not simply a momentary psychological state or passive contemplation, but consists of an "activity of the soul based on moral virtue," articulated with rational deliberation and prudence.phronesis).

In this way, being virtuous and achieving happiness in polis It does not depend on purely abstract knowledge, but on the constant updating of human potential through habits and deliberate choices.


2. Justification for the Correct Answer (Letter D)

The alternative D) Improvement of human behavior That's the correct one.

According to Aristotle, no one is born morally virtuous by nature; individuals only possess the innate capacity to embrace virtues, which develop and become consolidated through habit.ethosAs explained in the texts:

  • Text I emphasizes that excellence occurs "throughout life", materializing in "performance, conduct, behavior, disposition".
  • Text II reinforces that moral virtue is a **"provision directly linked to the deliberation"**That is, a stance consolidated through the constant practice of making choices weighed by reason and oriented towards "doing well".

Therefore, the repeated practice of just acts creates a just person, and the practice of courageous acts creates a courageous person. The implementation of virtues in life in society (polis) stems precisely from the continuous improvement of human behavior, shaped by the daily practice of rational deliberation and the consolidation of good habits.


3. Critical Analysis of Distractors (Refutation of other alternatives)

  • A) Theory of essential forms: Incorrect. The theory of ideas or intelligible (essential) forms belongs to Plato, Aristotle's teacher. Aristotelian ethics breaks with the transcendent Platonic model by proposing an eminently practical and immanent reflection, centered on concrete human actions and achievable goods in this world.
  • B) Identification of rational principles: Incorrect. Although reason and prudence are fundamental in the deliberative process (as per Text II), the mere theoretical identification of rules or principles is not sufficient to make someone virtuous. Virtue requires the translation of these principles into effective action and repeated habit.
  • C) Development of rhetorical techniques: Incorrect. Aristotelian rhetoric is a technique (techné) focused on persuasion and public speaking, constituting a discipline distinct from ethics, whose central objective is righteous conduct, character, and the good life.
  • E) knowledge of true epistemologies: Incorrect. In the Aristotelian classification of knowledge, the episteme It refers to theoretical, scientific, and universal knowledge of that which is immutable and necessary. Moral virtue, on the other hand, belongs to the realm of the contingent (that which could be otherwise) and demands practical wisdom (phronesis), not merely demonstrative epistemic knowledge.