Skip to main content
Humanities and their TechnologiesMediumSingle Choice

Humanities and their Technologies Question

Statement

I missed the future. Of course, I knew, long before its recurrence, that I would never grow old. It was very likely that I would never again see the ocean from a height of thirty thousand feet, a distance so great that one cannot even distinguish the waves, nor any boat, in a way that makes the ocean seem like a huge, infinite monolith. I could imagine it. I could remember it. But I could not see it again, and it occurred to me that the voracious ambition of human beings is never satiated when dreams are realized, because there is always the feeling that everything could have been done better and be done again.

GREEN, J. The Fault in Our Stars. Rio de Janeiro: Intrínseca, 2012.

The text presents a reflection by the character on a problem characteristic of contemporary philosophy, which deals with (the)

#contemporary philosophy#existentialism#human finitude#philosophical reflection
A

ethical implications.

B

human finitude.

Correct
C

limitations of language.

D

existential presupposition.

E

objectivity of knowledge.

Resolution & Explanations

1. Contextualization and Overview

The excerpt presented is part of the novel. The fault lies with our starsIn John Green's novel, the narrator-character reflects on her condition as a young person living with a serious and potentially fatal illness. Upon realizing that she "would never grow old" and that she "missed the future," the character projects her individual experience onto a universal reflection on life.

In contemporary philosophy—especially in phenomenology and existentialism (with thinkers such as Martin Heidegger and Jean-Paul Sartre)—the human being is understood from the perspective of their temporality and their inescapable relationship with mortality (being-towards-death). This text directly engages with this tradition by contrasting the brevity of life with the incessant human desire to project oneself into time.


2. Justification for the Correct Answer (Option B)

The correct alternative is B) human finitude.

The passage is structured entirely around an awareness of the temporal and biological limits of existence:

  • Awareness of mortality: The unequivocal realization that she would "never grow old" and the feeling of "lack of a future" make explicit the narrowing of the character's life horizon, marking the imminent end of her existence.
  • Loss of the possibility of repetition: The expression "never again to see the ocean from a height of thirty thousand feet" illustrates how the approach of death closes off the range of possible experiences and moments. The ocean, described as a "huge and infinite" monolith, acts as a metaphor in contrast to human life, which is brief and limited.
  • Contrast between unlimited desire and limited time: By observing that "the voracious ambition of human beings is never satisfied," the text exposes the existential paradox between the human yearning for continuity and improvement ("everything could have been done better and be done again") and the insurmountable barrier of death, the essence of the concept of finitude.

3. Critical Analysis of Distractors (Refutation of other alternatives)

  • A) Ethical implications: Ethics focuses on value judgments, the morality of actions, duty, and interpersonal conduct. The text does not address dilemmas of moral choice or criteria of justice, focusing solely on temporal perception and the limits of life itself.
  • C) limitations of language: Contemporary philosophy of language discusses the limits of the ability of signs to express objective reality or internal states (as in the works of Ludwig Wittgenstein). In the excerpt, the character does not report an inability to express what she feels; she articulates her feelings with conceptual and poetic clarity.
  • D) Existential presupposition: The term refers to formal logic and the philosophy of language (the commitment that a denotative term refers to a real, existing object) or, in Sartrean existentialism, to the ontological thesis that "existence precedes essence." The text does not investigate the ontological foundations of existence nor the logical requirements of predication; its focus falls on the practical and temporal dimension of the end of life (finitude and mortality).
  • E) Objectivity of knowledge: This is a topic within the field of epistemology, which investigates the reliability, method, and neutrality of the apprehension of reality by the knowing subject. The narrative presents a subjective, poetic, and existential reflection on lived time and death, not a debate about the validity of scientific or rational knowledge.